For a Free Quote Call Now: (262) 226-9451

Average Cost of Tearing Off And Replacing a Roof

Date: March 1, 2023

The average cost of tearing off and replacing a roof can range from $8,000 to $15,000 depending on the size of the roof, the type of materials used, the complexity of the job, and geographic location.

Replacing a roof is one of the biggest and most important investments you can make in your home. It requires the expertise of a professional roofing contractor and it is essential to determine the average cost of tearing off and replacing a roof in order to budget accordingly. Other factors that will affect the cost include whether or not you need a permit for the job, how many layers of existing roofing need to be removed and replaced, and any special ventilation or insulation requirements for your climate zone. 

Factors like whether you choose asphalt shingles or metal roofing can also play into the cost. It's essential to understand all of these considerations before making your decision on how much to invest in roof repair or replacement.

Factors Affecting the Cost of Tearing Off And Replacing a Roof

Men Installing a roof in a new house

1. Roof Pitch and Size

Roofers calculate roof slope by determining how much height a roof has in a set horizontal measurement. Most residential homes have roofs with a slope of 3/12 to 8/12 and any roof that has a higher slope such as 9/12 to 12/12 can be more costly. 

2. Labor

Labor is usually the biggest expense when it comes to determining the cost of tearing off and replacing a roof. On average, roofing labor typically costs between $1.50 and $3.00 per square foot.

The number of workers needed and how much time it takes to complete the job will determine how much you'll have to pay for labor. Additionally, you may also need to factor in additional costs for safety equipment or permits that may be required by your local government.

Other factors that affect your roofing labor quote:

Roof Condition: The condition of your roof and any underlying issues that need to be addressed can also affect the total cost. Extensive roof damage such as the rotting timbers underneath the shingles or rotting wood under the roof can make the job more difficult and dangerous. Most roofing companies would charge additional costs because they will need more time and equipment to ensure the safety of roofing professionals while completing the roofing replacement. 

Weather Condition: Extreme heat or cold weather condition can also be a factor roofing professional considers when charging a roofing replacement cost. Extreme weather conditions will require them to have additional equipment to protect themselves while working. 

3. Materials

The cost of tearing off and replacing a roof can be high and complex when it comes to choosing the right material. The price of roofing materials typically ranges between $150 and $1,500 per roofing square. You can choose from asphalt shingles, raised-seam metal roofs, and clay, concrete, or slate tiles. Depending on the material you choose, the cost of replacing a roof can vary drastically. 

4. Location

Location plays an important role when it comes to the cost of repairing or replacing a roof. The cost can vary greatly depending on the location, as different places have different labor costs, building regulations, and weather conditions.

For example, if you live in a place where there is more rain or snowfall then your roof will require more maintenance and thus increase the cost of repair or replacement. Similarly, if the labor cost is higher in your area then it will also contribute to the overall cost of getting a new roof for your home.

It is therefore important to consider all these factors when looking into getting a new roof for your home. Understanding how location affects your roofing cost can help you make an informed decision and save you money in the long run.

Roof Overlay Vs. Tear Off

Man installs a roof

Roof tear-off refers to the entire old roof that is to be removed completely, and the new roof is to be installed in its place with all new materials. This may be necessary if the existing roof has become damaged or aged to the point where its condition makes it unsafe or unstable.

Tearing off a roof provides several advantages to homeowners:

  • It removes any existing layers of old shingles or materials.
  • It creates a clean surface for new material installation and helps reduce labor costs associated with the job. 
  • It can also help to identify problems with underlying sheathing or other hidden issues that could lead to costly repairs down the line.
  • It allows you to change out rotted decking and properly install the roof's membrane.

Overall, opting for a roof tear-off instead of simply installing new shingles over existing ones can be a great investment in your home’s safety, comfort, and value. It will also help ensure that you get quality service from your chosen roofing service provider as well as reduce the overall cost associated with replacing a roof.

However, there are a number of disadvantages associated with this process that need to be taken into consideration before making a decision:

  • Increased construction costs, increased risk of further damage, and potential disruption to surrounding structures and services. 
  • Additionally, a lack of expertise from contractors in performing these types of tasks can result in expensive mistakes and delays. 

As such, homeowners should always do their research and consult with experienced professionals prior to deciding on whether or not roof tear-off is the right choice for their particular situation.

Close up image of a roof

Roof Overlay is a cost-effective and efficient alternative to roof tear-off. It involves applying a new layer of roofing material over the existing one, without needing to tear out the old shingles. 

Here are the advantages of opting for Roof Overlay:

  • ​​It is cheaper and saves you from having to pay for a full roof replacement, which can be expensive and time-consuming. You can save about $1,200. 
  • By using this method, your roof will look brand new in minimal time and at a fraction of the cost. 
  • You don’t have to worry about disposing of old shingles or paying for additional services such as gutter cleaning or chimney repair that may be needed with a full roof replacement. 

With an overlay, you get all the benefits of a new roof without having to go through the hassle and expense of replacing it completely.

While this can be a cost-effective way to repair or upgrade your existing roof, it does have some disadvantages too:

  • Voids some warranties from manufacturers & shortens the life of your shingles. For example, a shingle life is shortened because the attic now has two layers making it hotter to bake the shingles faster. 
  • It doesn't allow you to inspect decking material or install proper underlayments 
  • There are certain issues that can arise from layering two or more roofs, such as the potential of moisture in between layers, inadequate drainage, and ventilation which may lead to premature wear and tear.
  • The additional weight of the new roof could also cause structural damage to the walls or foundation of your home. 

Overlays may not meet the building code requirements in some areas. Therefore, it is important to seek professional advice before undertaking this project.

Replacing or repairing a roof can be a daunting task and it is important to understand the differences between roof overlays and a roof tear-off and all the factors that may affect the cost of roof repair and replacement. It will help you make an informed decision when it comes to choosing the right roofing service for your home.

Ways to Cut Down the Cost of Tearing Off And Replacing a Roof

Photo of a roof

When it comes to repairing or replacing a roof, costs can quickly add up. But there are plenty of ways to keep the cost down without sacrificing quality.  With some research and careful decision-making, you can save money on your roof replacement project without compromising on quality or service. Here are a few tips that can help you cut down the cost of tearing off and replacing when it comes to your roofing needs.

  • Compare quotes from different contractors and opt for cheaper materials.
  • Shop for quality roofing materials that are on sale.
  • Schedule the roof replacement a year or two before the end of the roof’s life. You can also consider getting a roof replacement while the damages are still manageable. 
  • Be aware of roofing service scams. Only hire the most reputable and trusted roofing company in your area. 

Replacing an old roof can be a hefty expense but being aware of all the available roofing options and their respective costs will help you pick the most cost-effective solution for your needs.

137 Wisconsin Ave
Waukesha WI 53186
(262) 226-9451
© Copyright 2023 Modern Exterior Roofing. All Rights Reserved. Website & Marketing by DUSK Digital.