For a Free Quote Call Now: (262) 226-9451

Plastic Gutters vs. Aluminum Gutters: A Comparative Analysis of Costs

Date: August 7, 2023

When it comes to protecting our homes from rainwater damage, gutters play a crucial role in channeling water away from the roof and foundation. Among the various gutter materials available, plastic gutters and aluminum gutters stand out as two popular choices. Each option has its advantages and drawbacks, leading homeowners like you to ponder which material best suits your needs and budget. 

In this post, we will explore the key differences between the two gutters, examining factors such as cost, durability, installation, and overall value. By shedding light on these essential aspects, we aim to assist homeowners in making an informed decision when choosing the right gutter material to safeguard their homes effectively. Let's dive into the comparison of these gutters to find out which option prevails in the battle of function, longevity, and cost-efficiency.

Lifecycle Costs:

Plastic Gutters:

These gutters are initially cheaper, making them an attractive option for budget-conscious homeowners. However, their lower cost comes at a price, as these gutters tend to have a shorter lifespan and are more susceptible to damage from the elements, such as UV rays and extreme weather conditions. Over time, continuous exposure to these factors can lead to cracks, warping, and leaks, necessitating repairs or replacements. 

Consequently, while they might be an economical choice in the short term, they may end up costing more over the lifetime of the home due to frequent maintenance and replacement expenses.

plastic gutter

Aluminum Gutters:

On the other hand, these gutters may require a higher upfront investment, but they offer significant advantages in the long run. One of their most appealing features is their exceptional durability, which allows them to endure harsh weather conditions without sustaining significant damage. These gutters are rust-resistant, making them ideal for regions with high humidity or frequent rain.

Furthermore, their sturdy construction and longevity mean homeowners won't have to worry about replacing them as often as plastic gutters. By opting for aluminum gutters, homeowners can enjoy peace of mind and potentially save money on repair and replacement costs in the long term, making them a more sensible choice for those seeking lasting performance and value for their homes.

aluminum gutter

Cost: Aluminum and Plastic Gutters

On average, the installation cost for vinyl gutters typically ranges from $3 to $7 per linear foot. This price encompasses various essential components, such as the sealant or plastic cement necessary for effectively sealing the gutter joints. It's worth noting that all PVC gutters are designed to be sectional rather than seamless, meaning they come in pre-cut segments that need to be pieced together during installation. 

While the average cost range for aluminum gutters per linear foot, encompassing labor and material expenses typically falls within the range of $15 to $20. Keep in mind that these figures represent a general range, and actual prices can vary significantly based on several crucial factors. Factors such as the brand and quality of the aluminum and plastic gutters, the specific location of the installation, and the prevailing market conditions in the area can all have a substantial impact on the final cost.

Cost of Installation:

1. Plastic gutters are generally easier and quicker to install than aluminum gutters. Their lightweight nature and flexibility make them easier to handle and manipulate during the installation process. Additionally, these gutters often come in pre-cut sections, further simplifying the installation for professionals. This ease of installation can lead to reduced labor costs since the job can be completed more efficiently and in less time. Plastic gutters can be an appealing option due to their straightforward installation process and potential savings on labor expenses.

2. Aluminum gutters tend to be heavier and less flexible than plastic gutters. As a result, their installation often demands the expertise of a professional to ensure a proper fit and secure attachment to the home's structure. Specialized tools may also be necessary for cutting and shaping these gutters accurately. Hiring a professional installer can add to the overall cost of installing aluminum gutters.

aluminum gutter


The choice between plastic and aluminum gutters goes beyond the initial cost and requires careful consideration of various factors. While plastic gutters may seem attractive due to their lower upfront expense, their shorter lifespan and susceptibility to damage may lead to higher costs over time. On the other hand, aluminum gutters, despite a higher initial investment, offer long-term value with their durability and extended lifespan. 

By seeking assistance from reputable professionals, assessing the benefits of higher-quality products, and considering the specific needs of your property, you can make a well-informed and personalized choice. Remember, gutters are not merely functional elements but a vital investment in the protection and longevity of your beloved home.

137 Wisconsin Ave
Waukesha WI 53186
(262) 226-9451
© Copyright 2023 Modern Exterior Roofing. All Rights Reserved. Website & Marketing by DUSK Digital.